Mystery Spice | Surprise Yourself!

Rated 5.00 out of 5 based on 2 customer ratings
(2 customer reviews)


Go ahead ~ surprise yourself and buy a mystery spice! It’ll be a regular size-spice bag for just $7 (valued at $10-$13+ depending on what you get!).

Have some fun and get a fresh, high quality herb or spice blend to experiment with. It could be anything from a flavored gourmet salt to a high quality organic herb or spice to a small batch, handcrafted Pinch seasoning – you won’t know until it arrives at your door!  If you have purchased previous mystery spices… and want to make sure we don’t send you a “repeat mystery spice” please notate on order what we’ve given you in the past. We mix it up a lot and try to prevent that, but sometimes duplicates happen.

  • spice burlap gift bag

2 reviews for Mystery Spice | Surprise Yourself!

  1. Rated 5 out of 5

    Robert Magill (verified owner)

    What a fun treat. I bought several boxes with various spices. This was just the perfect addition and was “on my list” for my next order.

  2. Rated 5 out of 5

    Sherry Troutman (verified owner)

    This place is amazing! It is so easy to order and spices can be shipped or you can choose a “no contact” pick up in a locker outside their door. They even have a spice vending machine in the hallway! I bought Taste of Louisville” boxes as gifts for out of town relatives and a mystery spice for myself. It was a taco seasoning that I can’t wait to try! These folks are so nice. I will definitely be ordering more!

Add a review

Your email address will not be published.

Mystery spice will come in a 2-4 ounce sized bag (weight depends on density of spice)

Weight 4 oz