Mystery Spice | Surprise Yourself!

Rated 5.00 out of 5 based on 8 customer ratings
(8 customer reviews)


Go ahead ~ surprise yourself and buy a mystery spice! It’ll be a regular size-spice bag for just $7 (valued at $10-$14+ depending on what you get!).

Have some fun and get a fresh, high quality herb or spice blend to experiment with. It could be anything from a flavored gourmet salt to a high quality organic herb or spice to a small batch, handcrafted Pinch seasoning – you won’t know until it arrives at your door!  If you have purchased previous mystery spices… and want to make sure we don’t send you a “repeat mystery spice” please notate on order what we’ve given you in the past. We mix it up a lot and try to prevent that, but sometimes duplicates happen.

We offer the following gift wrap options:

  • Make Your Own Spice Gift Bag (Green or Tan Burlap Bag)

8 reviews for Mystery Spice | Surprise Yourself!

  1. Rated 5 out of 5

    Robert Magill (verified owner)

    What a fun treat. I bought several boxes with various spices. This was just the perfect addition and was “on my list” for my next order.

  2. Rated 5 out of 5

    Sherry Troutman (verified owner)

    This place is amazing! It is so easy to order and spices can be shipped or you can choose a “no contact” pick up in a locker outside their door. They even have a spice vending machine in the hallway! I bought Taste of Louisville” boxes as gifts for out of town relatives and a mystery spice for myself. It was a taco seasoning that I can’t wait to try! These folks are so nice. I will definitely be ordering more!

  3. Rated 5 out of 5

    Amelia Ramiz (verified owner)

    We ended up with the southwest melange. First, the dune reference made me laugh out loud. Second, this was the spice mix i didn’t know i needed. Tried it on grilled pork chops and it was amazing.

  4. Rated 5 out of 5

    Steven (verified owner)

    I’ve bought at least ten of the mystery spices over the past six months, and it was an economical way to get out of my comfort zone and try some spices and blends I might not normally sample. I haven’t had a bad one yet, and I’ve been able to “gift” some that have more heat than my wife likes.

  5. Rated 5 out of 5

    Deveta Sneller (verified owner)

    When I ordered the mystery spice I was super excited to see what I would get and was pleasantly surprised when I got the Buffy the Slayer Blend. It has become the one I grab instead of minced garlic when I make my spaghetti sauce or just need to add a punch of flavor to any meat I am cooking. It will definitely remain in my spice cabinet in the future.

  6. Rated 5 out of 5

    Laura McMinn (verified owner)

    Thought I’d try a mystery spice, and recorded the ranch dressing mix. It’s fabulous! And great for those of us who are avoiding inflammatory oils and chemicals/preservatives! Now if you could just make a dairy-free version…

  7. Rated 5 out of 5

    Christy (verified owner)

    Love this mystery spice idea! I just tried it for the first time and was awarded the onion soup dip mix. Fabulous!

  8. Rated 5 out of 5

    sobegold5678 (verified owner)

    A cool way to try different spices and seasonings. The onion soup mix i got this time is fantastic

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Mystery spice will come in a 2-4 ounce sized bag (weight depends on density of spice)

Weight 4 oz